Trouble submitting to database- SIMBAD name not recognized

vrapson
Affiliation
American Association of Variable Star Observers (AAVSO)
Mon, 01/09/2023 - 20:29

Hi all,

I am attempting to submit some exoplanet light curve data to the database and keep getting the following error about the star name not being recognized by SIMBAD:

There were errors in your form. Fix these issues to continue:

  • Problems with report file KELT-23b-AAVSO-Submission.txt
  • The star name (000-BNC-329) is not recognized in Simbad

The star is KELT-23 (which is recognized when using the identifier query in SIMBAD). I also tried the following names, with no luck...

000-BNC-329   (the AAVSO AUID)

BD+66 911

2MASS J15283520+6621314

KELT-23 A

Any thoughts on this issue? This is my first time trying to make a submission so maybe I am missing something simple? I've pasted the top part of my submission file below.

#TYPE=EXOPLANET
#OBSCODE=RVAB
#SOFTWARE=AstroImageJ v5.0.0.00
#DELIM=,
#DATE_TYPE=JD_UTC
#OBSTYPE=CCD
#STAR_NAME=000-BNC-329
#EXOPLANET_NAME=KELT-23 A b
#BINNING=1x1
#EXPOSURE_TIME=20
#FILTER=V
#DETREND_PARAMETERS=Airmass
#MEASUREMENT_TYPE=Rnflux

JVannini
Affiliation
Liga Iberoamericana de Astronomia (South America) (LIADA)
Hello!

Try with TOI-1165 b
…

Hello!

Try with TOI-1165 b

SIMBAD offers you with several different names from other catalogues. And the TOI designation is recognized.-

Clear skies!

vrapson
Affiliation
American Association of Variable Star Observers (AAVSO)
Thanks, that worked! I'll…

Thanks, that worked! I'll use TOI designations if the regular star names don't seem to work in the future. 

JVannini
Affiliation
Liga Iberoamericana de Astronomia (South America) (LIADA)
Nice!

I would recommend not…

Nice!

I would recommend not sticking to one or two designations.

Exoplanets names are coming in different formats and AAVSO may not have them all. So if a name does not match, try a different catalog.

It is part of the fun! 😉